Beware of the Herd

October 22, 2024
Camelia Schwartz

Alameda, California, United States

Class of 2026

Read more from this author →

Herd mentality kills innocents in every generation. October 7, 2023, is today's version of the Salem witch trials. 

The first book we read this year in English class was The Crucible. I initially thought, “Ugh, why do we have to read this book?” But I learned that Arthur Miller, in writing The Crucible, wanted to show that when people just follow the herd in their thinking, it leads to chaos. His message is as true today as ever. 

Herd mentality is when, out of fear or ignorance, individuals copy what they perceive everyone around them is doing or thinking. The Crucible describes the Salem witch trials, which occurred in the late 17th Century. Women who were slightly different were called witches and murdered by mobs following a herd mentality. 

The Salem witch trials are not the only time in history where herd mentality had deadly consequences. Herd mentality was dangerous again during the Red Scare in the 1950s (at the time Arthur Miller was writing) and is dangerous again today. During the Red Scare, any divergence in a person would immediately raise suspicions that they were a communist.

We see events like this, where all are expected to believe one thing when one's thoughts are suppressed. To think independently is to admit to guilt.

This was the first year celebrating the High Holidays since the October 7th terrorist attacks in Israel. As I walked up the steps of my temple on Rosh Hashanah, tallis bag in hand like always, this year was different. While there is always security, especially on the High Holidays, as anti-Semitism remains prevalent, this year, I was greeted by the Oakland Police Department. Their badges caught the light in the too-hot, early October afternoon. 

Having police protection for our annual New Year’s services is not an overreaction. When people in the East Bay in Northern California wish “death to the Jews,” these are the precautions needed to ensure our safety. Herd mentality among those who have been adopting anti-Semitic attitudes requires this level of security.

The “Free Palestine’’ movement seems to be driven by herd mentality. While maybe there are people who genuinely care about the well-being of innocent people, it is safe to say that a good amount of these “Free Palestine” protests are not calling for peace: they are calling for Israel’s destruction. Today it is not uncommon to see a sea of keffiyehs pour into the streets, with people chanting phrases such as “from the river to the sea,” calling for the eradication of the seven million Jews of Israel. It is herd mentality like in the Crucible and like during the Red Scare. Especially here in the Bay Area, our youth are acting like sheep, brainwashed into thinking that all Jews are killing innocent Palestinians.

This is what leads to the greatest horrors being committed. This is what led to the very prevalent antisemitism that we have seen since October 7th. This is why sometimes I stand alone now because I am not willing to conform to the herd.

Camelia Schwartz is a BBG of Oakland BBG #2 from Central Region West and loves to ski.

All views expressed on content written for The Shofar represent the opinions and thoughts of the individual authors. The author biography represents the author at the time in which they were in BBYO.

Explore More Stories

Spotlight

2023 Must Reads!

Ella Young
Michigan, United States

In need of a good book? Or want to start reading and want to know where to start? This list is for you!Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo by Taylor Jenkins Reid: This book is amazing! It centers around a popular Hollywood actress, Evelyn Hugo, and all about her life story. It is very fun to read, and has a HUGE plot twist! Daisy Jones and the Six by Taylor Jenkins Reid: Interested in music? You should read Daisy Jones and the Six! In this story, you learn about a band that becomes very popular, and all the ups and downs they face. It is a super entertaining read and is being turned into a TV show in March 2023! It Ends With Us by Colleen Hoover: This story follows Lily Bloom, a girl who recently moved to Boston, and ready to start her new life. Through the book, you see how Lily evolves, and deals with a very impactful account. This book is so good, you won’t be able to put it down! All We Ever Wanted by Emily Giffin: Emily Giffin tells a very impactful story about an event that happens, and three different perspectives about it. The book highlights difficult topics, and shows how multiple people can change a story. The ending is very emotional, and definitely a book to add to your read list! Paper Towns by John Green: A story of adventure, romance, and mystery, Paper Towns is a book that keeps readers on their toes! It shows the dynamic between Margo, the most popular girl at school, and Quentin, a socially awkward boy who lives across the street from Margo. After one crazy night together, Margo disappears and leaves clues for Quentin to find her. This story will keep you on the edge of your seat! Malibu Rising by Taylor Jenkins Reid: It is August of 1983, and super Nina Riva is getting ready to throw her annual end of summer party. This book shows how in 24 hours, a LOT can happen. Malibu Rising is a super fun read, and shows how the different Riva kids can change in one day. Today Tonight Tomorrow by Rachel Lynn Solomon: Like to read books about academic rivals? This story is for you! Rowan and Neil have been rivals, but after they are forced to team up, things change for them. This is a super cute book with a sweet ending!

Get The Shofar blasted to your inbox

Subscribe
Subscribe